When a salaried employee is still owed overtime
A salaried employee is still owed overtime unless the job passes BOTH tests: earn at least $684/week AND perform specific duties (real managerial authority, independent judgment, certain professional categories). Pay a salary but skip the duties test, and the employee is "salaried non-exempt" — owed overtime at 1.5× their hourly equivalent for any hour past 40.
The trap: many "salaried" employees who fail the duties test never have their hours tracked because the employer assumed salary covered everything. When records are missing, a court can let the employee's reasonable estimate carry the claim. A coordinator paid $50,000 who claims 10 unpaid OT hours/week, doubled by federal liquidated damages across 2-3 years, adds up fast. One misclassified role can affect every worker with the same job duties.
How to handle salaried non-exempt employees
- Review every salaried position — confirm the duties test, not just the salary.
- For anyone who fails: switch to non-exempt and track hours per day and per week.
- Pay 1.5× the hourly equivalent for every hour over 40 — federal rule.
- Keep hour-by-hour records for at least 3 years (longer in CA, NY, HI).
- In CA, PA, or AK, don't use the "fluctuating workweek" half-time method — banned.
Where salaried non-exempt cases get expensive
- The "project coordinator" paid $45,000 who follows a procedure your office wrote — fails the duties test, owes 2 years of unpaid overtime.
- The "shift manager" who can't hire, can't fire, and supervises no one — same trap, same back-pay.
- The salaried admin who routinely works 50-hour weeks and whose hours were never tracked — federal law lets her estimate stand.
- Trying the federal "half-time" overtime shortcut for a salaried non-exempt employee in California — banned, every workweek is a separate violation.
When in doubt, track the hours
The "salaried = exempt" assumption is one of the easiest wage-and-hour mistakes to make. The salary is only half the test; the job duties are what decide whether overtime still applies. If you ever have to defend the exemption, the best support is a record of the hours actually worked — track them for every salaried employee, even the ones you're certain are exempt. Without that record, the employee's estimate can become the starting point.